Military Management Style Not Good For All Businesses

With so many veterans returning from war andValley Association of Startup Entrepreneurs)
to jobs they left, be it management, seniorbelieves that small businesses are better off with
management positions or business owners thea team of partners and collaborators than a
military touts the veteran's ability to lead amilitary organization. According to him not just for
organization. Jack Yoest writing for Small Businessthe small ones but also for large organizations that
Trends indicates that some small business ownersis why so many military commanders flock to the
have a desire to run a company like a military unit.Fortune 1000 companies. Mr. Erdos had the
The business owner understands, almostmisfortune of working for a Navy Captain turned
instinctively, that there are unique managementCorporate VP who he said resorted to shuffling
strategies that military organizations employ toaround his management team every six months
accomplish difficult missions. And perhaps die inand was a master of alienating customers.
the attempt. To sacrifice the last full measureIs a military type system right for small business
would be, to say the least, a motivated employee.and corporations? I think the answer lies in the
Mr. Yoest list three qualities that seasonedcompany goals and organization culture. In large
business leaders would look for in a militaryorganizations the the impact of strict controls
person or concept.may not have an adverse effect on the total
1. Persuasion, the ability to influence a point oforganization because of other internal and external
view and enlist a following. Not blind obediencevariables. But with a small company the effect
2. Discipline, "the prompt obedience to orders".would be felt from the top down. Small
Compliance is necessary for a team to function.companies operate under fragile conditions with
3. Field Expedient Methodology, using simple tasksthe owner or boss in close proximity to
and jobs to mold organizations. Flexibility andeverything and with more direct controls. More
Innovation.strict requirements would lead to diminished
Former Pawan Hans Helicopter chairman andmorale, loss of productivity, absenteeism and a
managing director A. Natarajan says" If you gohigh turnover rate.
back in history, all management techniques haveAccording to P. Keskonis and KM Siddiqi who did a
been drawn from the Army. It is aboutstudy concerning the factors that affect small
motivating men to deliver in the face of evenbusiness failure said "As we enter the twenty-first
death.century, employee morale as it pertains to profits
Bhaskar Ghose, managing director of IndusIndand lost production appears to be a major
Bank states that "command and discipline is theconcern.
best thing that corporations can learn from theManagements of small business contracting firms
military".need to recognize employee morale as a critical
But not everyone agrees that militaryissue for profitability. Since morale affects profit
management qualities and are best for civilianand productivity, it is extremely important to
organizations and businesses. Zoli Erdosunderstand the factors that influence morale and
Editor-in-Chief, Program Chair, SVASE (Siliconthe rationale behind these factors Keskonis said.